Verbal Tips Are Fraud

The concept of the Verbal Tip is understood by any waiter who has been in the business for more than 2 or 3 . . . shifts.

‘You were the best waiter!’

‘Thank you so much! You were really great tonight!’

I truly hope some of these particular diners are reading this, so they can understand we know what they are doing. But then, the kind of diners who pull this shit are definitely not interested in how the waiter feels about things. So why should I expect they would seek out a waiter blog?

Verbal Tips are as intrinsic to food serving as:

  1. Skating on sidework.
  2. Getting free drinks from the bartender (during or after your shift).
  3. Hitting on the hostess or hitting on the bartender (depending on your inclinations).

An exhaustive list? By no means.

The idea here is that every waiter knows about, understands, and has gotten Verbal Tips.

Frankly, Verbal Tips are one of the most reviled ‘features’ of food serving. Bear with me, but the most common refrain from the waiter is something like, ‘Everything was perfect! Nothing went wrong. They were happy. They said they were happy. The food was great. Nothing came out late. We talked . . . and F’n 10-percent!’

The Verbal Tip is fraud. That’s right. Just like Bernard Madoff said he was giving you a solid return in relation to your contribution. In reality he was keeping the money himself. Here’s how it breaks down for Bernie Madoff (and for Verbal Tippers):

  • We give good faith (service or money).
  • He keeps the money.
  • We get the words.

It’s fraud because these people are redefining the interaction of service and tipping. Just like Madoff and his ilk redefine the concept of investment and returns. There is only one definition for tipping. The guest gives the waiter money commensurate with the quality of the job done. Notice there are no commas, or dashes, or parentheses in that sentence. There are no loopholes. This commandment is etched in stone as much as the Employee Manual Moses’ brought down from the mountain.

The Verbal Tipper has defiled this universal law and twisted it into: ‘I will substitute some kind words for a certain amount of money.’

Look, a commendation and a pat on the back is great from your mom or your kindergarten teacher. It’s also nice from your employer, but your boss doesn’t say, ‘Hey, great job today – and by the way, because I just recognized you verbally, I’m reducing your paycheck 10% this week.’

Besides being fraud, Verbal Tipping is ridiculously condescending. Think about the mindset.

‘The real prize for this waiter is not making money and surviving. It is the honor of serving me. If I leave mere money – heck, anyone can do that, and it’s just perfunctory – he won’t appreciate it. I’m going to give him something way more valuable than money. I’m going to let him know that I approve of him.’

Thanks, guy.

Verbal Tippers are also liars (as differentiated from being perpetrators of fraud, a bigger lie). They are liars because they espouse a ‘philosophy’ as quoted above, but the true motivation is not to approve or reward. It is to save money. Everyone knows that waiters make minimum wage (or less!). Are Verbal Tippers also going around ‘rewarding’ and ‘approving of’ the girl running the fitting room at The Gap? How ’bout our favorite, the cashier at the 7-11? I’ve never heard anyone give the old Verbal Tip to the 7-11 guy. Or the dude hawking flowers at the freeway off-ramp? Or the young man selling magazine subscriptions door-to-door?

Verbal Tippers reserve their special reward for only those situations where it can save them from withdrawing money from their wallets.

Let this be the rule from here forth – no, wait. This has always been the rule: A Verbal Tip shall only, and we mean only, be administered as a reinforcement or supplement to the real, actual, concrete money tip that has been given. If the guest feels there has been excellent service, then the statement will be the percentage of tip awarded. If the guest feels he wants to ‘supplement’ the waiter’s tip at this point, then he can go right ahead and commend him verbally for his competence and his personality and his full head of hair. Anything at all. But the Verbal Tip is only to underline what his actual tip has already stated.

Thank you.


5 thoughts on “Verbal Tips Are Fraud

  1. SkippyMom Fri, June 5, 2009 / 4:06 am

    I really never, ever ran into verbal tipping when I waitressed. I would get the nice words, but the tip would match. It wasn’t until I started reading the internet that I found out that servers hate this and were worried that they wouldn’t be tipped if I complimented their service.

    Being a former waitress we always tip 22% up to 50% [usually around 30%] we are ridiculous tippers, but we appreciate good service. Still, I hesitate to ever verbally tip any server before they see the tip because I don’t want them to get mad and think we aren’t going to tip.

    We do alleviate it this somewhat by frequenting our fav’ places and are known as regulars, who tip well and our verbal matches our money.

    • waiternotes Fri, June 5, 2009 / 2:30 pm

      That surprises me, SkippyMom. What kind of restaurant/price level did you work at? I’d be interested to know if there’s a possible difference there.

      I personally don’t care if I get ‘complimented’ before I see what the tip is. I don’t get a bad attitude about it until I see I got reamed. Because, you’re right of course, compliments do often accompany good tips.

  2. Kate Thu, November 29, 2012 / 12:06 pm

    I know this is an old article, but I just found your blog and wanted to share this particularly bad tipping story: I was managing a small cafe that did terrible dinner business. The girl who waitressed at night typically only came home with $20 or so. Well, one night two ladies come in, stay for hours, and rack up a $150 bill (avg there was around $25 for two). The waitress is jazzed. She’d been chatting them up and the ladies were praising everything. She drops the check and they hand her a credit card. She runs it, brings back the check, and the ladies verbally tip her profusely. After they leave, she picks up the check and glances in at the tip line: $0. The only other thing in the check presenter is a little business card with a cross that said “Got Sin?”

    From that day forth, I was always worried when people praised me as a server, unless it was a regular who I knew would tip well.

  3. workerstories Fri, March 3, 2017 / 2:07 pm

    Hi,I just came across your awesome blog. Great reading! I edit WorkersWrite, a website that showcases the stories workers tell about their working lives. I’d like permission to reprint on our website “Verbal Tips Are Fraud.” Of course, we would credit you, and link back to your site. Please let me know if that would be okay. Thank you!

    Rose Imperato
    Editor, WorkersWrite

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s